Best Bully Sticks for Dogs (Long-Lasting Single-Ingredient Chews)

A good bully stick keeps a dog busy for a long time, and many owners use them to redirect chewing away from shoes and furniture. One owner says her dog loves them so much she uses them during grooming. They are single-ingredient beef chews, but they are still a chew that needs supervision.

This guide covers sizes, odor, how bully sticks compare with other chews, and four bully sticks owners buy most.

Short version: Natural Farm’s 12-inch odor-free sticks are the top seller. Mighty Paw’s 12-inch sticks are the lower-odor alternative from a family-owned US company. Natural Farm 4-inch sticks suit small dogs and puppies, and Jack&Pup’s thick 6-inch sticks are made for medium and large power chewers.

Bully Sticks vs. Dental Chews vs. Toys

Bully sticks are edible beef chews that last a while but get used up. Dental chews are made to be eaten quickly as part of tooth care. Nylon and rubber toys are not eaten at all and suit dogs that destroy edible chews fast; see our toys for aggressive chewers. Bully sticks are not a replacement for brushing; our dog toothpaste and brushing kits guide covers that.

Size and Odor

Choose a stick your dog cannot fit in its mouth whole. Small dogs and puppies do better with shorter sticks, while big, strong chewers need thick ones. All bully sticks have some natural smell. Natural Farm sells its sticks as odor-free, and Mighty Paw says its sticks are lower odor but may still have a natural scent.

The Picks, Up Close

Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks, 12 in, 5 count

Natural Farm 12 in — Check price on Amazon

Odor-free 12-inch sticks that Natural Farm says are made from USDA-certified grass-fed beef, cleaned with water only and slow oven-baked. It says nothing goes in but 100% beef: grain free, hormone free and chemical free.

Best for: Most dogs, as a long-lasting reward.

Mighty Paw 12 in Bully Sticks

Mighty Paw 12 in — Check price on Amazon

Single-ingredient, 100% beef sticks with no artificial preservatives, colors or flavors. Mighty Paw says they are lower odor, though they may still have a natural scent, and sells them as an alternative to rawhide for power chewers. It is a family-owned company based in the USA.

Best for: Owners who want another top-selling 12-inch option.

Natural Farm 4 in Bully Sticks for Small Dogs & Puppies

Natural Farm 4 in — Check price on Amazon

A shorter 4-inch size of Natural Farm’s odor-free, grass-fed beef sticks, made for small dogs and puppies. Supervise closely and remove the end piece early, since short sticks reach a swallowable size sooner.

Best for: Small breeds and puppies.

Jack&Pup Thick 6 in Bully Sticks, 5 pack

Jack&Pup 6 in — Check price on Amazon

Extra-thick 6-inch sticks made for medium and large dogs that love to chew. Jack&Pup says they are single-ingredient beef with no rawhide, from cattle raised without added hormones or antibiotics.

Best for: Medium and large power chewers.

FAQ

Are bully sticks safe?

They are a popular single-ingredient chew, but always supervise and remove the last small piece. Ask your vet if your dog has health issues.

How often can my dog have a bully stick?

They add calories, so treat them as part of the daily treat allowance. Your vet can advise for your dog.

Do bully sticks clean teeth?

Some listings say chewing helps remove plaque, but they do not replace brushing or vet dental care.

My dog finishes a bully stick in minutes. What now?

Try a thicker stick, or a durable toy from our dog toy guide.

Final Take

Natural Farm’s 12-inch sticks are the top pick, Mighty Paw is a strong alternative, the 4-inch size suits small dogs, and Jack&Pup’s thick sticks suit power chewers. Whatever you choose, stay with your dog and take away the end piece.